“My first reaction to this production is the incredible performance of Matthew Gittins as Curly. This is the most natural and honest interpretation I have ever seen. From the moment he arrives, his easy and down-homeness are supremely engaging. Thanks to his parents’ gene pool, Gittins cuts a handsome figure on stage and becomes the perfect cowboy matinee idol. His voice is perfect in the belly of R&H, and he conveys all the emotions necessary by not overplaying, but just honest fine acting.”

- Keven Kelly, Cleveland Stage Alliance

“The Legend of Georgia McBride is a slight comedy by Matthew Lopez, but with the right talent and direction, it works. One reason is Matt Gittins as Georgia. It’s an underwritten role, but Gittins musters so much power and nuance, the character - and his drag characters - come to life!”

- Howard Gollop, The Chronicle-Telegram

“Gittins’ sparkling tenor is the star of the show. He makes the most of Andrew Lippa’s catchiest score, digging his teeth into surging anthems like “Be The Hero.”

- Richard Sanford, Columbus Dispatch

"Gittins… does a stunning job of making Old and Young Joe feel like the same person with similar inflections and body language…and radiating a genuine goodness."

- Richard Sanford, Columbus Underground

"Matthew Gittins as Billy Crocker has a gorgeous voice.  Watch for this young actor; you'll see him again."

- David Ritchey, West Side Leader

"This Porthouse production boasts fine acting, particularly by Gittins as (Jack) Kelly... who possesses a quality for which there is no Tony Award - unbridled passion!”

-Bob Abelman, Cleveland Jewish News

“Millie… sets out to land a rich husband (a wryly amusing Matthew Gittins)…who boasts an operetta number that permits Gittins to showcase both vocal ability and comic chops”

-Margaret Quamme, Columbus Dispatch